donation letterHave you ever dreamed you have a test that you didn’t study for?

It’s a common nightmare when you feel anxious, and that’s not a feeling you want going into the year-end giving season.

That’s why you make a plan based on what you learned last year and where you are so far this year. More often than not, your year-end plan will include at least one donation letter because studies show people of all ages like and respond to mail.

It’s tempting to dive headfirst into writing these printed appeals. But there are a lot more moving parts to getting a fundraising letter done right and out the door making money.

Completing a creative brief will help you manage the process.

A creative brief is a tool that helps you outline all the strategic and creative requirements for a fundraising campaign. The brief we use at Abeja Solutions includes these categories of questions which we’ve found to be useful with nonprofits of all sizes:

Team & Communications

Decide upfront who needs to be involved in the creative process. Even if you’re officially a team of one, you probably still have partners, such as a volunteer who’s great at design or a printer who gives you a smoking deal.

Clarify now how each partner will contribute. That will keep people focused on their tasks and minimize those last-minute surprises that make mailings late and more expensive. With your team in place, agree on a single way to share and store files.

Purpose

Zero in on why you’re communicating and set a goal that’s measurable and realistic. Then, list all the items you’ll create for the campaign. Following Sandy’s 3:1 Ratio, you’ll balance your ASKS (e.g., donation letter, reminder postcard for nonrespondents, and appeal support emails) with THANK YOUS (e.g., phone call from a board member, video, or a holiday card) and REPORTS (e.g., print newsletter or year-in-review emails).

Postage

Consider the pros and cons of different mailing options and choose one based on your timeline, budget, and status with USPS. With postage rates at a record high, it pays to take a second look at the ways you may be able to save money, time, and sleepless nights as a nonprofit commercial mailer.

Production

What’s your preferred mail date? If this is your first letter, give yourself at least 10 weeks – from completing the creative brief to your letter arriving in donors’ mailboxes. That will give you time to pivot if someone gets sick or the printer can’t source the envelopes you want.

Next, what is your plan to print, fold, stuff, address, and deliver your package to USPS? Will you assemble your mailing in-house or is it wiser for you to use an experienced print/mail vendor?

Mailing List

This section of the brief will help you think about the size of your mailing, who will pull the mailing list, and who on your team needs to receive the letter in addition to donors.

Individual giving programs run on clean, reliable data. If your database needs work before the year-end fundraising season, decide now whether you can make the fixes yourself or need to source a vendor who specializes in data hygiene.

Audience

You already know your donation letter needs to look and feel like a one-to-one letter to a friend. To get there, write down what your donors have in common. Think about demographics (gender, age, income, family makeup, etc.), as well as psychographics (beliefs, values, and hobbies). What one thing will you ask them to do, why should they respond now, and what will they receive in return?

Narrative

Save time in the writing phase by identifying your letter’s value proposition to donors. That’s a short statement that summarizes why they would choose to give to you versus a similar nonprofit. Hint: It’s more about what your donors need to hear than what your nonprofit wants to say. Your audience profile is going to come in handy here! Next, what emotional focus story will grab donors’ hearts? Is there a fact or two you need to include so donors understand what’s at stake? What tangible difference will donors make with their gifts?

Design

These questions will help you source images and design a letter that makes it easy for donors to give – especially those with older eyes. Remember the intent of your letter is to raise money, not win design awards. The more personal and readable you can make it look the better!

When your creative brief is complete, place it in a shared folder that your team can access over the length of your project. If any changes occur — such as a decision to switch focus stories or increase the print quantity — note those in the brief. Not only will that keep your current project running like a dream, but your brief will be an important record to consult when planning your year-end donation letter next year.

The Bottom Line

A creative brief can help you fully prepare for each stage of the donation letter process. By doing the hard work of thoughtfully planning your letter and gathering your resources upfront, you can avoid a nightmare scenario at the post office.

Instead, you can rest easy knowing your donation letter has the best chance of success.

About the Author:

Laura Ingalls is CEO of Abeja Solutions, a women-owned small business that helps nonprofits nationwide master direct mail, and the co-author of “How to Fundraise by Mail: A Digital Native’s Guide.”

Woman with shoulder-length dark hair wearing blue-framed glasses, navy blazer, and light blue top, smiling at camera against white background.