Fundraising in a small nonprofit can be tough.

You wear a lot of hats and it’s easy to feel like the Lone Ranger.

There’s always more to do than time to do it, and some of it sits so far outside your comfort zone that your heart starts pounding. Some of it feels like facing the Creature from the Black Lagoon while you’re stuck in knee-deep mud.

Here’s how I know. The first time I was responsible for fundraising, I had no idea what I was doing. My executive director handed me the budget and said, “Here’s what you need to raise. Good luck.” There was no training, no webinars, no online courses. I learned by doing, and plenty of what I had to do scared me silly.

So with Halloween this week, let’s look at the 10 scariest things about fundraising in a small nonprofit, especially when you’re the one in charge. And because I don’t want to leave you shaking in your boots, I’ll share what helps with each one.

1. Speak in public. 

Standing up in front of a group to explain what your nonprofit does can be nerve-wracking. You have to remember what you want to say, say it in the right order, stay within your time, and inspire people to get involved or give. Even those of us who speaking in public a lot feel the pressure to perform. If you’re newer at it, it can feel as terrifying as facing the velociraptors from Jurassic Park.

What helps: Pick three key points and write them on an index card. Practice out loud at least twice. And end with one short story about a person your nonprofit has helped. People remember stories long after they forget statistics.

2. Shoot video/be on TV.

The thought of a camera pointed at you makes a lot of people want to run and hide. What if you mess up? What if your hair is sticking up or there’s spinach in your teeth? Video is a powerful tool for fundraising, and being on TV is a great way to spread the word. But even people who’ve done it many times still get butterflies. If you haven’t done it much, it’s as unnerving as meeting a werewolf under a full moon.

What helps: Done beats perfect. Record on your phone and picture yourself talking to one favorite donor instead of an audience. Watch it once, then post it before you talk yourself out of it.

3. Letting a volunteer go

A lot of nonprofit leaders are people-pleasers, and that makes tough decisions even tougher. Asking a volunteer to leave can have your heart racing and your palms sweating. After all, they’re donating their time, right? But not every volunteer is right for the job they’re in. Sometimes you can move them to a role where they’ll shine. Other times, especially when they’re stirring up drama, you have to ask them to leave. It’s as unsettling as hearing a strange noise in the house when you’re sure you’re alone.

What helps: Clear written role descriptions from day one make this conversation much easier. When it’s time, be kind, brief, and clear. Thank them for their time and keep the focus on the role, not on them as a person.

fundraising in a small nonprofit4. Tell someone “no.”

Most people in nonprofit work are kind-hearted. They’re there to help, so saying “no” goes against the grain. Too often, saying “yes” to someone else’s great new idea means saying “no” to yourself. Before long you’re overworked and stressed out, which doesn’t leave you in good shape to do the work you’re there to do. It’s frightening what one little word can do.

What helps: Know your top fundraising priorities for the year, then measure every new idea against them. Try something like, “That’s a great idea, and it’s not something we can take on right now.”

5. Face the checkbook.

If you’re not a numbers person, looking at the bank balance can leave you breathless. It’s worse when you’re not sure there’s enough to cover everything that needs to be paid. It’s like walking in the woods at night and hearing a chainsaw fire up.

What helps: Look at your numbers on the same day every week. Knowing is always less scary than wondering. If you need help reading the reports, ask a Board member or volunteer with a finance background to walk through them with you.

6. Talk with a donor about their death.

Sitting down with a donor can be scary enough. Talking about a planned gift means talking about the donor’s eventual passing, and that can make the bravest fundraiser tremble. A planned gift, when a donor leaves your nonprofit in their will, is the ultimate donation. Until you build the skill and confidence for this conversation, it can leave you gasping for air like a night in a haunted house.

What helps: You don’t have to start with death. Start with legacy. Ask, “Have you ever thought about the difference you’d like to make for the future?” And add a simple line to your newsletter and website letting donors know they can include you in their will.

7. Deal with difficult Board members. 

Most people serving on a nonprofit Board don’t fully understand their job. Without that understanding, some micromanage or meddle where they shouldn’t. Others get a taste of power and start throwing it around. When your Board is technically your boss, telling them to settle down or stop directing front-line staff can make you want to run. But it has to be done for the good of the nonprofit.

What helps: Get Board roles and expectations in writing. Build a strong relationship with your Board chair so you have an ally. And handle issues privately and early, before they grow fangs.

fundraising in a small nonprofit8. Calling a foundation to ask about funding

So many people hate the phone. Others hate asking for anything. Put those together, and calling a foundation to see if your program fits their interests can feel worse than facing a vampire alone in a dark alley.

What helps: Script your first 30 seconds. Remember, you’re not asking for money on this call. You’re asking whether you’re a good fit. Program officers want good fits as much as you do. Practice makes it easier, just like carrying a wooden stake and garlic.

9. Take a call from an angry donor.

It happens. A donor’s name gets misspelled or left off a list. Or worse. Suddenly it’s like you accidentally created Frankenstein’s monster, and now they’re on the phone, upset. To fully fund your budget, you need a big, loyal donor base, and that means having hard conversations with unhappy donors.

What helps: Listen without interrupting. Thank them for telling you. Fix it, then follow up to let them know it’s fixed. A donor whose problem is handled well often ends up more loyal than before.

10. Ask for money face-to-face. 

This is the ultimate scary fundraising experience. It’s you and the donor, eye to eye, and it’s time to make the Ask for a large donation. Your heart thunders, you’re sweating, and your mouth is so dry you can hardly get the words out. Asking in person for a major gift is one of the most productive uses of your time. For those who are new to it, it’s also one of the most terrifying. Like your worst nightmare come true.

What helps: Every Ask needs a goal, impact, and deadline. Practice saying your Ask out loud until it feels natural. Then, once you’ve asked, stop talking and let the donor answer.

Scary stuff, right?

Some of these probably make your stomach drop more than others. Maybe there’s something not even on this list that kicks your heart rate up.

Here’s the thing. Every fundraiser I know has felt their heart race over at least one of these. I still get butterflies sometimes. That doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong. It means you’re stretching.

And the more you face your fears, the smaller they get. When you talk about money, you raise more money.

Which one of these scares you most? Or is there something else that gets your heart racing? Share it in the comments below. Chances are, someone else reading this feels the same way.